cargo securing solutions
DunLash Ultra container desiccants

Container Desiccant Comparison

CaCl2 vs Clay vs Silica Gel — Which Desiccant Protects Your Cargo Best?

The Three Main Container Desiccant Types

Three desiccant technologies are commonly offered for shipping container moisture control: calcium chloride (CaCl2), montmorillonite clay, and silica gel. They differ significantly in absorption capacity, mechanism, cost per container, and suitability for different cargo and voyage profiles. Understanding the differences is the foundation of choosing the right product for your specific application.

In addition to our container desiccant comparison, we offer a full range of cargo protection and moisture control solutions:

Calcium Chloride (CaCl2) — DunLash Ultra

Calcium chloride is a hygroscopic salt that absorbs moisture from the air and converts it into a calcium chloride solution — a gel that is locked inside the desiccant bag. CaCl2 desiccants continue absorbing moisture as long as conditions remain above the saturation point, meaning they remain effective throughout long voyages with multiple dew-point cycles.

DunLash Ultra 750g contains 625g of CaCl2 at 95% purity plus natural fibre. It is manufactured by IDS International and distributed by DunLash Systems across South Africa.


Clay Desiccant (Montmorillonite) — PacDry

Montmorillonite clay is a naturally occurring mineral that adsorbs moisture into its crystal structure. It is chemically inert, low-cost, and effective at lower humidity levels. However, clay desiccants reach saturation at a lower absorption level than CaCl2 products and — critically — release moisture back into the air when temperature rises. This makes clay less effective for container applications where temperature cycling is significant.

DunLash PacDry is a montmorillonite clay primary desiccant sized in desiccant units per US MIL-D-3464E. It is recommended for primary packaging applications — small enclosed spaces such as instrument cases, electronics packaging, and sealed cartons — rather than the large air volume of a 20ft or 40ft shipping container.


Silica Gel

Silica gel is the most widely known desiccant type, familiar from the small sachets in footwear, electronics, and pharmaceutical packaging. Like clay, silica gel adsorbs moisture physically rather than chemically. It reaches saturation at relatively low absorption levels (typically 20–30% of its own weight) and releases moisture when temperature rises — the same limitation as clay when used in container applications with significant temperature cycling.

Silica gel is well-suited to small, temperature-stable enclosed spaces. For large container air volumes and voyages with significant temperature variation, it does not provide the sustained absorption performance that CaCl2 desiccants deliver.


Absorption Performance — The Numbers

DunLash Ultra has been independently tested against competitor desiccant products under controlled conditions replicating real container voyage humidity and temperature profiles. The test data compares absorption performance at 30°C across humidity profiles from 70% to 90% relative humidity — the range encountered in containers during typical ocean voyages from South Africa.

Test ConditionDunLash Ultra 750g
30°C / 80% RHAbsorbs up to 250% of bag weight
30°C / 90% RHAbsorbs up to 300% of bag weight
28°C / 70% RHAbsorbs up to 150% of bag weight
Temperature cycling (30°C – 70°C profile)Retains absorbed moisture as gel — does not re-release

The critical finding: DunLash Ultra 750g delivers greater total moisture absorption than a competitor product weighing 1.1kg — 47% heavier. The advantage is most pronounced at the higher humidity levels (80–90% RH) that are most damaging to cargo — precisely the conditions encountered when containers are packed in humid coastal environments or cross the equator.


The Re-release Problem — Why It Matters for Container Voyages

For short, temperature-stable storage applications, all three desiccant types perform adequately. The critical difference emerges during sea voyages with significant temperature variation.

Clay and silica gel desiccants adsorb moisture physically. When the temperature rises — which happens every day as the container warms during daylight, and more significantly when the vessel moves between climate zones — the absorbed moisture is partially released back into the container air. This means a clay or silica gel desiccant that absorbed moisture during the cool night cycle releases it again during the warm day cycle. The net moisture removal is far lower than the raw absorption capacity suggests.

DunLash Ultra CaCl2 does not have this problem. The calcium chloride reacts chemically with absorbed water, locking it as a gel. This reaction is not significantly reversed by temperature increases within the range encountered in standard sea voyages. The moisture absorbed stays absorbed for the duration of the voyage.


Which Desiccant for Which Application?

ApplicationRecommended DunLash Product
20ft or 40ft GP container — sea freightDunLash Ultra 750g
Reefer containerDunLash Ultra 750g
Primary packaging — electronics, instrumentsPacDry (Montmorillonite clay)
Primary packaging — pharmaceuticalsPacDry or silica gel
Long-haul road freight in sealed containersDunLash Ultra 750g
Short-haul road freight, low humidityPacDry or lower-spec option

Cost Per Container — A Realistic Comparison

Some buyers choose clay or silica gel because the per-unit purchase price is lower. This comparison changes when evaluated on a per-container, per-voyage basis:

  • DunLash Ultra absorbs up to 250% of its weight. A standard 40ft container requires 8 x 750g bags = 6kg of DunLash Ultra, capable of absorbing up to 15kg of water.
  • A clay desiccant bag rated at equivalent absorption would need to weigh significantly more than 750g to match this performance — and would still release a portion of its absorbed moisture during temperature cycling.
  • The cost of a single damaged container — even a partial loss — typically far exceeds the cost saving of using a lower-performing desiccant. One mould claim, one corroded shipment, or one label-damage rejection at destination erases many months of desiccant cost savings.

Why Choose DunLash for Container Desiccant Protection

DunLash supplies moisture control and cargo protection products for South African exporters, freight forwarders, agricultural producers, packhouses, logistics companies, and food cargo operators. Our solutions help protect cargo from condensation, container rain, mould growth, packaging collapse, corrosion, and moisture-related claims during road, rail, and ocean freight.

DunLash can assist with desiccant dosage recommendations based on cargo type, container type, voyage duration, route profile, pallet moisture, and specific export requirements.

Frequently Asked Questions — Desiccant Comparison


Can I use silica gel or clay desiccants in place of DunLash Ultra?

For container moisture control during sea freight — particularly long voyages, equatorial crossings, or high-humidity loading environments — DunLash Ultra is the recommended product. Clay and silica gel can be used for supplementary primary packaging protection, but they do not provide equivalent container-level moisture control due to lower absorption capacity per gram and moisture re-release under temperature cycling.


Is there independent test data for DunLash Ultra vs competitor products?

Yes. DunLash has independent absorption performance data comparing DunLash Ultra 750g to competitor desiccant products (including a 1.1kg competitor product) at test conditions of 30°C and 70–90% relative humidity. DunLash Ultra delivers superior absorption performance at high humidity levels despite weighing less than the competitor product. Contact DunLash to request the test data.


What is the difference between adsorption and absorption in desiccants?

Adsorption (clay, silica gel) holds moisture on the surface or within the crystal structure of the desiccant material — a physical process. Absorption (DunLash Ultra CaCl2) involves a chemical reaction between the desiccant material and water molecules, locking moisture as a gel. Absorption is more resistant to moisture re-release under temperature changes, making CaCl2 desiccants more effective for container applications with significant temperature cycling.


Contact DunLash to discuss the right desiccant solution for your container cargo and voyage requirements.

Related Resources

Lashing Product Range

  • Buckles

    Eliminating damage to your cargo

  • Lashing Tensioners

    A wide range of tensioners to meet every requirement

  • Lashing Accessories

    A comprehensive range of complimentary accessories

  • Edge Protectors

    Edge protection to protect and unitise cargo

Need Assistance? Let one of our specialist consultants get in touch with you today.